Jun 17, 2008 05:20PM GMTJune 17, 2008 17:20:20

Question Stats

1,923 answers
1,351 comments
raves +71 -8
Share This Question

Did Miley Cyrus with her song "Rockstar" rip off Lustra's song "Scotty Doesn't Know"?

Listen to Lustra's "Scotty Doesn't Know" and then listen to Miley Cyrus' song "Rockstar." See if you notice any similarities between the two songs, keeping in mind that Lustra's version came first. Did Miley Cyrus aka Hannah Montana rip off Lustra's music? *The first answer choice is Lustra's "Scotty Doesn't Know," and the second is Miley Cyrus' "Rockstar."
Add Image Add Video
resize

* these fields are required to answer

I agree to the SodaHead TOS and Privacy

Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +10   by Apple

Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

What NO ONE seems to know (If you knew ANYTHING about Miley, you would know this), she DID NOT WRITE THAT SONG! The song Rockstar is a song written for the character Hannah Montana and was put on a Hannah Montana album. I don't particularly like Miley or Hannah but ignorance just annoys the HECK out of me. Songwriters for the show write the Hannah Monatana songs. Miley has nothing to do with them until they are sheet music in front of her and she is learning and performing them. She has nothing to do with the songwriting process of Hannah Montana songs, she only writes the Miley songs (which Rockstar is not).
view thread
Sort By: Raves | Date 1 2 3 4 ... Next » Last » Comments
  • raves     [-] by tinkerbell37

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    I HATE MILEY CYRUS!!! SHE IS A WITCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • raves     [-] by sHI

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    the beat is absolutely the same.
  • raves     [-] by GeGe

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    miley wouldn't i know that "cause if she did it wasn't on perpose and if someone thinks shedid "copy" then there just as ...... up as lustra
  • raves     [-] by ohmygerard

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    Shes a whore. And the top comment is wrong. That just makes her fake. Real artists write their own songs!
  • raves     [-] by DANIE

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    YEAH SHE PROBABLY DID I HATE THE CHICK SOOOOOOOO MUCH!!
  • raves     [-] by iceexangel

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    I miley cyrus rip artist similarities coincidence ALREADY LISTENED TO THEM, THERE'S NO WAY SHE RIPED THEM OFF. AND ANYWAYS, SHE DOESN'T WRITE THE SONGS.
  • raves     [-] by hi

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    That is not the same it really not the same I think it do not rip off she is another artist
  • raves     [-] by Le Jennio

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    The beginnings sound identical. Naturally, the lyrics are different, but the music is the same.
  • raves     [-] by jbfan#1

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    I THINK THAT EVERY ONE SHOULD STAY WITH THERE OWN THING
  • raves     [-] by kimmy

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    You say that just because you like her... Stop saying that it's a coincidence, it's TRUE !! She copied a song..
  • raves     [-] by michelle

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    OMGG I WAS THINKING THAT TOO!!!! EVERYTIME I HEAR DTHAT STUPID SONG I START SINGING SCOTTY DOESNT KNOW OMG I LOVE THATS ONG LOL i hate rockstar its a stupid song she can barely sing it anyway wow i thought i was the only one that thought that lol
  • raves     [-] by lilly

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    yes she did the guitar riff is almost the same it is
  • raves     [-] by Not So Perfect

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    honestly idk
  • raves     [-] by Chanlebbbypht

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    all of mileys songs are orignal so fuck off
  • raves     [-] by britt

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    miley would never do that and it doesnt even sound the same
  • raves     [-] by emmybug

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    busted
  • raves +1   [-] by yonamie

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    o yea!!!
    miley isz a totall knokk off!!!
    thats why she has an overbite!!!!booo
    selina gomez and demi lovato are so mujj better than her nd many
    put 2gether!!!
    hahahaha!!!
    shess a totall skank!!!
  • raves     [-] by mileyfan

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    Mileys such an awesome person she would never do that to anyone. and if she did she made the other song more popular cuz idk anyone who has herd that Scotty Doesnt know song.
  • raves     [-] by bookie

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    um im not really sure but does it really matter?
  • raves     [-] by billsbi

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    miley cyrus can suck a fuck p.s. mileys gna die someday and ill throw flaming saks of dogshit @ ger tomb stone
  • raves     [-] by missa

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    moderated...
  • raves     [-] by Bubblez

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    im sorry i think she mooched a lil bit of dat song
  • raves     [-] by Kallie

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    No Miley would never do that! DUH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • raves     [-] by Tara

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    shes a messed up kid, but she normaly doesnt write her own songs someone else does.
  • raves     [-] by SaraMarieJonas

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    okay, as much as I hate Miley and would totally not be surprised if she did, she doesn't write her songs. (PATHETIC!)

    Sorry, but it's the truth, so obviously, her writers ripped it off, not her.
  • raves     [-] by becca

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    miley didn't do that, the songs sound different
  • raves     [-] by Crysti

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    Miley didn't write the song anyway!
  • raves     [-] by music_chick101

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    yeah...they sound exactly alike in the beginning riff and the melody!!
  • raves     [-] by fireware0062

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    everyone rips off some one else's music! especially these new comers they can't write or come up with something of their own! they all suck there's no art in what they do, it's something else!
  • raves     [-] by 25blueSkittles

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    LoL, She's fucking 15! You fucking stalkers. xDD I personally don't like her at all either but you guys are making her too big too fast. Of course she's gonna want to do more extreme (stupid) stunts. And I disagree with the "she's like all teens" that's not fair to teens are actually have a conscience and use their common sense. I say, she can't think for her self.
  • raves     [-] by holly

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    miley would never NEVER DO THAT!
  • raves     [-] by Sasifras

    Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.

    HANNAH MONTANA ROCKS!!!!!
  • raves     [-] by lily

    Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.

    miley would never do that
  • raves     [-] by Sam