Did Miley Cyrus with her song "Rockstar" rip off Lustra's song "Scotty Doesn't Know"?
Listen to Lustra's "Scotty Doesn't Know" and then listen to Miley Cyrus' song "Rockstar." See if you notice any similarities between the two songs, keeping in mind that Lustra's version came first. Did Miley Cyrus aka Hannah Montana rip off Lustra's music? *The first answer choice is Lustra's "Scotty Doesn't Know," and the second is Miley Cyrus' "Rockstar."
Loading...-
raves posted Jul 16, 2008 03:21AM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
im not a fan of miley but i kow that her dad writes her song it doesnt mean she riped of any song she just did wat she was told and i love the song scotty doesnt know but she is just 15 and she doesnt need all this inclduing with her fotos al teenagers do it if those other teens were celebs they will have the same talk about them like they are doing to miley everyone should just drop it its all nonscence and plus evryone remakes songs its no big deal unless she has permisson to use the guitar riff and th vocal melody and plus rihanna takes beats from the song called tainted love and no one is going wild over that situation -
raves posted Jul 15, 2008 11:34PM GMT
Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.
i dont trust the whole hannah montana thing anymore the whole scam wit her takin naked pics was wrong so who says she wont rip off a great song like tat wit a new name i mean come off it grow up if u cant make up ur own shit then forget it un! -
raves posted Jul 14, 2008 03:04PM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
They don't really sound the same to me. I don't know how they are. Mostly the song says "Scotty dosen't Know". Rockstar by Miley Cyrus says a variety of things. -
raves posted Jul 10, 2008 02:03AM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
no i dont think so because first of al she doesnt seem like that kind of person and second of all i have no clue who the heck lustra, or what ever, was. so what even if it did sound like it its probably a coincidence -
raves +1 posted Jul 09, 2008 09:39PM GMT
Answered Absolutely! The guitar riff and vocal melody are almost exactly the same.
I dont no u even though i love milley she is awsome but I have 2 admit that miley does sound exactly the same and that is just like u doing the same tht would make u mad now wouldnt it trust me i no -
raves posted Jul 09, 2008 03:06AM GMT (edited)
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
WHOA!!! i'm so excited 2 hear that miley Cyrus was stealing the vocal melody and the sound of the guitar from "Scotty doesn't know!" 2 tell the truth i don't even like her! MILEY SUCKS!!! I HATE her!! -
raves posted Jul 08, 2008 10:13PM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
Its a coincidence. Miley didnt write it. Maybe the songwriter doesnt have much life enough to make sure no other songs sound like it. Hannah sings songs written by other people. Miley on the other hand, writes her songs. So get a life and f****** deal with it! -
raves +1 posted Jul 08, 2008 03:12PM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
Although Im not a Miley Cyrus fan, there are only so many chord progressions in music. A perfect example would be Vanilla Ices' "Ice Ice Baby" sounding like the intro to "Under Pressure" by David Bowie and Queen. It may sound the same but the songs are so very different. So I wouldn't say it was entirely her fault. -
raves +1 posted Jul 08, 2008 03:07PM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
Ummmmmmm she may have used some of the music but when i read this i had no idea who scott w/e was so i think its fine as long as it aint the same song -
raves +10 posted Jul 08, 2008 06:07AM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
What NO ONE seems to know (If you knew ANYTHING about Miley, you would know this), she DID NOT WRITE THAT SONG! The song Rockstar is a song written for the character Hannah Montana and was put on a Hannah Montana album. I don't particularly like Miley or Hannah but ignorance just annoys the HECK out of me. Songwriters for the show write the Hannah Monatana songs. Miley has nothing to do with them until they are sheet music in front of her and she is learning and performing them. She has nothing to do with the songwriting process of Hannah Montana songs, she only writes the Miley songs (which Rockstar is not). -
raves +3 -2 posted Jul 07, 2008 10:33AM GMT (edited)
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
Why r u people always giving her a hard time!!!!! SO wat if they sound the same get over it and get a life !!!!!OK I mean she didn't write the f***ing song so wat does it matter she only sings it!! and if u guys got paid wat she does u would put on that damn hannah montana wig and sing ur f***ing hearts out!!! ok so don't talk about my girl like that! ALRIGHT!!!!
-
raves posted Jul 06, 2008 02:33AM GMT
Answered No way! Miley Cyrus would never rip off another artist. If there are similarities, it's a coincidence.
What NO ONE seems to know (If you knew ANYTHING about Miley, you would know this), she DID NOT WRITE THAT SONG! The song Rockstar is a song written for the character Hannah Montana and was put on a Hannah Montana album. I don't particularly like Miley or Hannah but ignorance just annoys the HECK out of me. Songwriters for the show write the Hannah Monatana songs. Miley has nothing to do with them until they are sheet music in front of her and she is learning and performing them. She has nothing to do with the songwriting process of Hannah Montana songs, she only writes the Miley songs (which Rockstar is not).