Apr 25, 2008 11:54PM GMTApril 25, 2008 23:54:22
Question Religion - Other
Posted by perks

Question Stats

201 answers
638 comments
raves +29 -3
Share This Question

Morality question: If you are walking past a body of water and you notice your dog/cat are drowning and about fifty yards away a woman is drowning and you can only save one, who do you save?

Add Image Add Video
resize
Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +23 -4 by Donald

Answered The woman

The value of a human life is more precious to our Father than anything ... He proved that through His Son, Jesus.
view thread
Sort By: Raves | Date 1 2 3 4 ... Next » Last » Comments
  • raves +1   [-] by MS

    Answered The woman

    The cat or dog will only lick my face as thanks
  • raves     [-] perks replied to MS
    LMAO, well said.
  • raves +1   [-] by Summer aka nina ;-) VP *MFBA*

    Answered The woman

    lol...
  • raves +1   [-] by Disfunctionalbuthappy

    Answered The woman

    I love animals but human lives are more important
  • raves +1   [-] by BeaverGunns

    Answered Undecided

    Not really undecided...but I? would save both, no one could tell me I could just save one....so, it would be SUPERBEAVER to the rescue!
  • raves +1   [-] by trader

    Answered The woman

    Human life is more important.
  • raves     [-] by Exile

    Answered The woman

    My animals wouldn't be stupid enough to be drowning :P they'd be swimmin circles around the women tryin to figure out why she's causing such a ruckus.
  • raves     [-] by Beverly

    Answered I can't swim

    oh goodness, i cant swim to save my own life!
  • raves +4   [-] by Squint

    Answered The woman

    To answer this question I'd have to know the political affiliation of the woman! In all seriousness, and with a heavy heart, I would have to save the woman. The value of human life vs animal life is clear to us all. There is a chance she will contribute to us all for decades to come. My dog will contribute to my life for only 10 years, or so. So with a heavy heart and tears streaming from my eyes, I would abandon my dog and save a woman who I would then insist must then cure cancer or do some other spectacular good for mankind. My dog was not to have died cheaply!
  • raves     [-] by csherm

    Answered Undecided

    Whichever I think I could realisticly save.
  • raves +1 -2 [-] by Tony

    Answered Your pet

    Save the dog. The woman is probably religious and probably has a 6 out of 10 chance of being a welfare recipient.
  • raves     [-] Exile replied to Tony
    And is there something wrong about being a welfare recipient?
  • raves     [-] by ~BINK~

    Answered I can't swim

    o God, if i try to go and save either one of them they would never get helped, then someone would be trying to save all three of us!
  • raves +2 -1 [-] by Don - K.M.R.I.A.

    Answered Your pet

    One is a companion of mine, and has been with me through many ups and downs. The other is a person I've never met. I'd rather risk my life for the victim I know and love.
  • raves +6   [-] by Rockies

    Answered Undecided

    I'd be like super man and swoop down and save them both...
  • raves +5   [-] Janet replied to Rockies
    Just make sure you pull me out first.
  • raves +5   [-] Rockies replied to Janet
    At the speed of light girlie...And be back home in time for dinner.
  • raves +3   [-] by mr niceguy

    Answered The woman

    save the woman- humans are more important than animals, and besides most animals have a natural instinct to swim. may not always look graceful but they usually swim and get to land. However, if i threw the woman in in the first place probably save the pet
  • raves +6   [-] by dahacks

    Answered The woman

    the woman maybe shell be gratefull and cook me dinner my dog alway;s weres a life jacket cat should learn to swim !
  • raves +3   [-] by jamie

    Answered The woman

    The human being of course.
  • raves +3   [-] by LoXx

    Answered The woman

    If she looks like the one in the picture I just clicked on for my answer, then the woman.
    Nah, I think I'd just save her anyway.
  • raves +3   [-] by AILDFAN

    Answered I can't swim

    I can barely keep myself afloat, but i would try to save the woman
  • raves +10   [-] by JDC

    Answered The woman

    I'm really surpised that some would even think twice of course it should be the WOMAN!
  • raves +7   [-] Janet replied to JDC
    JDC, I feel so bad for the people who picked the animal to save. It makes me wonder if they have ever really felt loved.
  • raves +3 -1 [-] by Sister Jean

    Answered The woman

    as much as I love Princess,I know the diff between people and animals and I would hope Princess would make it,too
  • raves +4   [-] by lolo

    Answered The woman

    That's a no brainer. I don't think anyone would actually go for the animal first, not in a real situation.
  • raves +4 -3 [-] by scrshaw

    Answered Your pet

    No question, my dog. Especially if the woman is someone I don't even know.
  • raves +2   [-] nltsierra replied to scrshaw
    I think its funny that all the people who picked woman are going around DR'ing us who didn't. Funny that they are such cowards but some how would step up in a crisis situation??? yeah right!
  • raves +1   [-] scrshaw replied to nltsierra
    That's their problem. If they want to go through life thinking that one species of animal has more right to live than another just because they happen to be a member of that species, then so be it. I just don't subscribe to that delusion and genuinely feel sorry for them. But like I said, that's their problem and they are the ones that will have to live with their choices.
  • raves +1   [-] nltsierra replied to scrshaw
    I love that answer =)
  • raves +1   [-] Squint replied to nltsierra
    C'mon Sierra not all of us who picked the woman are DR'ing anybody. This is not an easy choice and I fault nobody for choosing to save their dog. Besides, be happy when somebody DR's you because what you achieve, when someone DR's you, is to Out a toilet-dwelling coward, whose life is so empty, whose morality is so depleted, whose circle of friends and family is so empty, whose ability to express a cogent thought is so poor, that they are limited to throwing a rock and running like hell to preserve their anonymity.
  • raves     [-] nltsierra replied to Squint
    You are very correct on the DR issue that is why I wish those that DR would have to be announced, then they would only use it correctly, for when someone using foul language or explict language or pictures.
    But if you look through this poll the majority of the DRing went to those of us who picked pet, so much so that some of our answers are hidden.
  • raves     [-] trader replied to nltsierra