Question Celebrities

Should Miley Cyrus have posed topless for Vanity Fair?

raves +142 -77 by SodaHead Entertai...
Should Miley Cyrus have posed topless for Vanity Fair?
Miley Cyrus is speaking out about her 'near nude' shot in this months Vanity Fair. The photo, which was shot by the renowned Annie Leibovitz, shows the 15 year old Disney star topless with a satin sheet covering her chest. Through her publicist on Sunday, Miley attempted to explain herself. "I took part in a photo shoot that was supposed to be 'artistic' and now, seeing the photographs and reading the story, I feel so embarrassed. I never intended for any of this to happen and I apologize to my fans who I care so deeply about." Vanity Fair countered back with their own statement. "Miley's parents and/or minders were on the set all day. Since the photo was taken digitally, they saw it on the shoot and everyone thought it was a beautiful and natural portrait of Miley." So, do you think it was right of Miley to have done the photo?
Add Image Add Video
resize

* these fields are required to comment

I agree to the SodaHead TOS and Privacy

Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +123 -68 by Gina

Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

Can't believe she did this, she's only 15!
view thread
Sort By: Raves | Date 1 2 3 4 ... Next » Last » Comments
  • raves     [-] by KarlyIS

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    It is a beautiful, artistic picture. I'm 15 and I go to an arts highschool. I've seen more racy things in our gallery than what Miley's done. Hell, we even have a life drawing class in which you draw naked people!
    It's just a shot of her back. Nothing to get too worked up about. I'm 15. I could post a picture of my back on the internet and nobody would care. You might say she's a rolemodel for little kids... But, what is she "teaching" them by showing her back?
    I've seen little kids in bikinis. Ahh, I'll stop now.
    I think I'm beginning to rant, hahah. :)
  • raves     [-] by Arch8908

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    I think that anyone who believes this shot is "explicit" in any way is a fucking moron. I mean, I dont see any nudity. I dont see any sexually "motivating" actions or signs. And also, people are being so judgmental of Miley.. I mean. Jesus fucking christ. You should be more judgemental of that. What about porno. Every fucking teen knows about that but it doest mean they wanna be like Brittney Skye or Giana. I say leave the poor kid alone.
  • raves +1   [-] by Destiny

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    Miley didn't do anythin wrong shes showing her back you guys need 2 stop critazicing her.
  • raves     [-] by ani

    Answered Here's what I think....

    it's an ok photo but it was stupid that she did it
  • raves     [-] by Michael

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    what's the big deal she was all covered!!!
  • raves     [-] by jonasobsessive

    Answered Here's what I think....

    she is only 15 but they pushed her into this and her father was gone she should've called him immediatly...but everyone makes mistakes...leave her alone.
  • raves     [-] by sk8rgurl789

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    NO Way
  • raves     [-] by BB

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    she isnt naked but no one wants to see that. its not artistic, it dumb. shes not some playboy bunny (though i bet she wants to be). she keeps playing innocent and if she wants us to believe her, she should stop doing these ridiculous things! those kinds of poses are for women, not little girls who think they're hot.
  • raves     [-] by krickett09

    Answered Here's what I think....

    Miley is a bad girl!!!! miley girl
  • raves     [-] by Michael
    it's the same damn pictures all the time she is in a bikini whats the big deal!!! like you dont c that at the beach!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • raves     [-] by Crysti

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    She didn't really do anything wrong. Honestly, it's actually a nice shot with light makeup and people shouldn't critisize her for it. After all, her parents were part of it too.
  • raves     [-] by Jessica

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    Aside from everything else, it's a gorgeous shot. But yes, it was a mistake of because of her many young fans. Other than that, i see nothing wrong with the photo. It's not like she's showing anything. It's her back! And her parents were supervising the whole thing.
  • raves     [-] by rayray

    Answered Here's what I think....

    I think Miley should be kicked off disney channel for a month or 2!!! It really suprises me that Miley's parents were there with her,and now that happened, I don't want to be a fan of Miley's!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • raves   -1 [-] by MollyB

    Answered Here's what I think....

    [...] A: She's NOT topless...she'd be showing more if she was wearing a contemporary swimsuit. B: Who the fuck cares? Are your pathetic little lives so devoid of anything meaningful that even wondering about THIS kind of non-issue is worth your time? C. Again, who cares? Are you people so slow-witted that you can't tell this is a Disney PR stunt to boost her (incomprehensible in the first place) sales? D. Only religious nutbags would consider this fodder for discussion. [...]
  • raves   -1 [-] by PrincetonBeth

    Answered Here's what I think....

    Miley is setting the example that it is ok to be like the pics... and it isn't
    she has 6 and 7 year olds(aka the most inpressionable age) looking to her as a role model ! she supposedly took the vow of purity i think not cause the vow of purity states that you are supposed to be sexually pure in mind and body not just the body and i know cause i have taken the vow of purity!!! she sets the most awful example just not for children but for teens also!!
  • raves   -1 [-] by SaraMarieJonas

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    MY GOD!
    will she EVER stop!

    Seriously! She has 6 year olds looking up to her and she is taking NAKED PICTURES?? How stupid!
  • raves     [-] by Crysti
    Loosen up. She's not naked! All you see is her back. It isn't really that bad. After alll, her parents let her. It was supposed to be a clean, simple shot with light makeup. Give her a break!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And no, she's not stupid. She's actually a great star and that's why people admire her. BTW, there are young kids looking up to other stars like Britney Spears and stuff and they are much worse.
  • raves     [-] by jessicat

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    i don care wat people think she should have shes almost an adult so she should show herself off more ofte
  • raves     [-] by kyersten

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    We think yes and no. No because she sets a bad influence to all of her younger fans that think of her as a role model!! It could also ruin her reputation. Yes because it shows her nautral body as well as that she is growing up to become a young women. FROM: miley haters!!
  • raves     [-] by Meggie

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    she is giving all young children and teenagers the wrong ideas about her. She is setting a horrible example as a 15 year old/
  • raves +1   [-] by alexis

    Answered Here's what I think....

    Miley whas stupid for doing that!! not only has her ratings droped but she will lose respect from many people! Including me
  • raves   -1 [-] by kimweb

    Answered Here's what I think....

    jesus christ get over soooo she is 15 she is only showin her back and if you look at it with an open mind its a beutifull shot that petrays her innocence nothin else it is a beutifull artistic shot
  • raves     [-] by mileyfan#1
    thank u!! u understand dat its not a big deal people!!!!! its only her back i mean some girls even wear halter tops that show backs. this is nothing!!!!!!!!!
  • raves +1   [-] by princess

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    she is stupied and ugly so if u like her and want 2 b like her i feel so sorry 4 u good luck trying 2 be like her people and nick jonas i feel so so sorry 4 u u were her bf(boyfriend)so so sorry i would hate her and never talk 2 her at all not even if i was on tour with that ugly rotten stupied girl she is so stupied i bet all most every body hates her so i feel so sorry 4 all of u who liked or who still likes her dont worry life will get better and u all will see who she really is and i hate her but my bffs still like her and this boy loves her hes in my class his name is justice hes stupied 2 i hate him so so much!!!!!!
    she is stupied and ugly so if u like her and want 2 b like her i feel so sorry 4 u good luck trying 2 be like her people and nick jonas i feel so so sorry 4 u u were her bf(boyfriend)so so sorry i would hate her and never talk 2 her at all not even if i was on tour with that ugly rotten stupied girl she is so stupied i bet all most every body hates her so i feel so sorry 4 all of u who liked or who still likes her dont worry life will get better and u all will see who she really is and i hate her but my bffs still like her and this boy loves her hes in my class his name is justice hes stupied 2 i hate him so so much!!!!!!
  • raves +1   [-] by ava

    Answered Here's what I think....

    She is sooooooooo ugly and she is just going to end up like the spears family ( jamie getting pregnant and brittney is just a mess) most celebritys are sluts anyway
  • raves     [-] by Naty Purple

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    Terrible , deixa ela em paz
  • raves     [-] by Garlop

    Answered Here's what I think....

    I can't belive how repressed Americans are, emotionally, sexually and artistically. This is the kind of repression that leads to all the closeted scandals we hear about on a daily basis. Grow up America, people have sex, and yes there is sexuality in all of us, young and old. Annie Lebowitz is an incredible artist and the picture is absolutely beautiful. My only regret is that Miley was put in a position to apologize for something she should not have, I wish she had stuck to her guns.
  • raves +1   [-] by jazzy

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    she is a bad influence because little fans want to be like her when they grow up.
  • raves +1   [-] by IHATEMILEYCYRUS

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    I HATE MILEY CYRUS!!! SHE SUCKS SO MUCH!!! SHE DOESNT EVEN DESERVE TO BE FAMOUS. AND SHE IS SOO UGLY!
  • raves     [-] by shyqueen

    Answered Here's what I think....

    well... she was tryiing to be an adult and grow up to fast yes she did set a bad example in a way be she didnt now better she wanted to be sexy but she to young to know how to be cute/sexy girl but stay her age http://entimg.msn.com/i/mu/ar...
    Retna_150.jpg http://image.com.com/tv/image...
    20Best%20Hair%20(female)/best...
    well... she was tryiing to be an adult and grow up to fast yes she did set a bad example in a way be she didnt now better she wanted to be sexy but she to young to know how to be cute/sexy girl but stay her age http://entimg.msn.com/i/mu/ar...
    Retna_150.jpg http://image.com.com/tv/image...
    20Best%20Hair%20(female)/best...