Jun 04, 2008 02:41PM GMTJune 04, 2008 14:41:26
Question Schools - High School

Question Stats

133 answers
154 comments
raves +14  
Share This Question

Teen cancer patient not allowed to walk with graduating class.....what do you think?

She didnt get enough credits during her time of treatment....but the school won't even recognize her as class of 08.....





http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/us/2008/06/04/cancer.student...
Add Image Add Video
resize
Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +13   by ♫Lily♫

Answered Let her walk!!!!!

let her walk....she dident make her credits because she was fighting cancer....she can make them up in summer school, but let her walk!!!!
view thread
  • raves     [-] by Niki (6ft under the stars)

    Answered Undecided

    If she didn't really finish high school then why would she even want to go and be reminded of what she missed. but if she did want to go and then i don't see the problem they can just say her name they don't have to give her a diploma
  • raves +2   [-] by Nick

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    Let the girl walk. You don't even get your diploma at the ceremony anyway. She can walk and make up the credits later. I didn't get to walk at my graduation and it was devistating. You only graduate high school once. Let her share the day with her friends and family!
  • raves +2   [-] by Lauren

    Answered Sad, but she didnt make the credits....

    At the risk of having all of you sending me hate mail I'm going to have to agree with the principal. It is horrible that she got cancer, and I applaud her strength to survive, but she didn't get the right amount of credits. Walking across the stage at graduation and getting your diploma is saying that you completed all you needed to and have graduated, she didn't do that. I sympathize with her but her asking the principal to "just bend the rules a little bit" is not something that is justified. Not to mention unfair to those who worked to get the privilege of walking across the stage. Even if she did her classes over the summer, there's no guarantee she would pass them.

    I do think that there should be something mentioned about her at the graduation, acknowledging her hard work and courage during that tough time. I think denying that is cold hearted and sending the wrong message to the community.
  • raves     [-] jacobtree replied to Lauren
    Very well said, could not agree with you more. You said what I wanted to say but alot better then I would of.
  • raves +1   [-] Lauren replied to jacobtree
    Thanks :)
  • raves +1   [-] gamman replied to Lauren
    you don't receive the diploma crossing the stage but a 'diploma holder' - many cross the stage and have their names read at universities who are within a term of actually graduating - rather then have them wait another year
  • raves +1   [-] Lauren replied to gamman
    That may be the case in some high schools, but it seems that this school has different rules, so I stand by what I said. As for your reference to how universities run, I'm sure you realize that Universities tend to do things a little different than high school's do.
  • raves +2   [-] by NATIROCKS

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    It's not her fault she has cancer
  • raves     [-] Socrates (The Gadfly) replied to NATIROCKS
    The principal's email address is:

    Principalegenera@wjusd.org

    I say we all let her know how we feel about this....in mass....

    also, here is a link to a page with all the personnel's email addresses...

    http://www.whs.wjusd.k12.ca.u...


    have fun.
  • raves +1   [-] by nana

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    that is so sad that she cant walk at her own graduation. i would be mad as a young adult and dissapointed that i didnt get to finish high school. i mean if you had cancer and was in therapy or recovery or getting treated daily would you have time to do that. as a parent i would immediatly consult the school board and if it got too ugly i would sew.
  • raves +1   [-] by luigi1

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    the pc brigade rewards bad students yet no one is looking out for the good students. let her walk with her friends & classmates.
  • raves +1   [-] by Ashley

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    thats dumb just let her walk!!!!!!!!!!
  • raves +1   [-] by B.E.

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    There are some naive people in the world today.... Okay she dealing with cancer, and on top of that trying to fight for her life.... So they should understand that, and let her walk and whatever she did not continue with in school, while she discontinue it b/c of this cause, they she let her be able to make up the work in "SS"
  • raves +1   [-] by Eagle

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    If she was a good student before she fell ill, and was on track to graduate, she should be able to go with her class. It was not her fault she fell behind.
  • raves +2   [-] by Jazzielicious

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    dude she fuking fighting cancer!WHAT THE HELL? I mean come on now she didnt have time to do school cause she was fighting to live,let her walk she can make the credits up im summer school
  • raves     [-] Socrates (The Gadfly) replied to Jazzielicious
    The principal's email address is:

    Principal egenera@wjusd.org

    I say we all let her know how we feel about this....in mass....

    also, here is a link to a page with all the personnel's email addresses...

    http://www.whs.wjusd.k12.ca.u...


    have fun.
  • raves     [-] ♥Enchanted Twilight♥ replied to Jazzielicious
    Well put my friend!! :)
  • raves +1   [-] by Tiki

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    She deserves to be able to walk with her class, it's not her fault she was sick!
  • raves     [-] by LDM Yoga School and Radio

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    Sad, the real world reality is starting for her already. I have encountered so much unfair treatment. I have even gone to court for some issues, when you are passionate, the law is on your side with tons of any documentation. Well, may she be blessed anyway.
  • raves +1   [-] by Punky

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    i say let her walk, so what if she didnt meet the credit requirement.
  • raves +2   [-] by Raindropp

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    Thats fucked up she probably did her best and they could have at least let her walk
  • raves     [-] Socrates (The Gadfly) replied to Raindropp
    The principal's email address is:

    Principal egenera@wjusd.org

    I say we all let her know how we feel about this....in mass....

    also, here is a link to a page with all the personnel's email addresses...

    http://www.whs.wjusd.k12.ca.u...


    have fun.
  • raves +1   [-] alw_ays replied to Socrates (The Gadfly)
    The link doesn't work :(
  • raves +1   [-] Socrates (The Gadfly) replied to alw_ays
    http://www.whs.wjusd.k12.ca.u...


    sorry bout that...it will work if you click from here..
  • raves +3   [-] by taz

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    They should have let her walk with pride. She was fighting for her life,so
    her grades fell. Big Deal give her a break. People seem not to look fair
    on things until it happens to them and then they want understanding. Also,
    to ad my mom is very ill and was seeing a doctor for years and she
    had for breast cancer and one time she was to weak and sick to go to her
    family doctor and with a 4 day notice he still wanted his money and had
    nerve to dismiss her as a client. How rude! The sick and the old should
    be shown respect cause one day we will get old and hopefully not sickly
    The lack of caring and kindness and morals and values are gone today
    people care about themselves only . Its is sad . I am christian and the last
    time the world got this bad God flooded the earth so, people need to think
    about history repeats itself...A old saying is "you get what you give". Show
    no mercy get no mercy. There is summer school to make up
    the credits lacking!!!!
  • raves     [-] ♥Enchanted Twilight♥ replied to taz
    Couldn't have said it any better my friend!!! :)
  • raves +1   [-] by Shenay

    Answered All of the above

    All of the about but the "sad, but she didnt make the credits"
    How in the hell does the school baord expect her to come to class, or even do home work when shes going threw something like that?
    WTF exactly!?
    Let her walk!
    Shes obviously been threw A LOT!
    And she has cancer...
    does the school board realize that she might not even live to see 2009?
    how selfish is that...?
    and its not like shes in the 10 or 11th grade...its was her senior year!
    LET her walk!!! live 2009 selfish shes 10 11th grade senior year walk
  • raves     [-] Socrates (The Gadfly) replied to Shenay
    The principal's email address is:

    Principal egenera@wjusd.org

    I say we all let her know how we feel about this....in mass....

    also, here is a link to a page with all the personnel's email addresses...

    http://www.whs.wjusd.k12.ca.u...


    have fun.
  • raves +1   [-] by rhstarr

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    Thats just stupid, if she did the work they should let her walk. I mean she was sick. Its not she skipping like most teens. That just messed up.
  • raves +1   [-] by Jenny

    Answered WTF?

    what a loser principal
  • raves     [-] by sandy

    Answered Let her walk!!!!!

    Let her walk , If her grades was good enough when she was in class and the treatments were her reasons for not walking I think she should be allowed to walk with her class , because with the strength to return was a bout of its own ,. It so easy for one to judge when you have not walk in that person shoes. She doesn't need excuses and reasons to stop her from walking. She need encouraging and a reason to walk
  • raves +1